Meeting Miss Silver

A couple of weeks ago I was at a very fine local pub. As well as keeping an excellent selection of ales, this admirable establishment also holds a pile of used books which you can browse over a beer and take home with you if you put 50p in their book-fund teapot. Thus it was that after a couple of tasty pints and perusing the used book pile, that I chanced upon a most handsome volume. It was a slightly battered hardback book, featuring a fabulously melodramatic cover illustration, and designed with the simple lines, scriptive typefaces, and saturated colour-schemes of the 1950s. Everything about the book as an object was pleasing to me, and the pages had a fantastic aroma of ink and time.

Flicking the book open, I read the synopsis, and was intrigued to explore the volume further:

Miss Silver is in Ledshire again for her twenty-seventh case. Shrewd as ever, armed with her quotations from Lord Tennyson and her knitting, she patiently probes into a muddled business of anonymous letters, village feuds made worse by elderly gossips, suicide and murder.

It is my habit to flick through a couple of pages before deciding whether or not I will “get on” with an author, and in this process, my eyes fell happily upon the following phrase, which sold the book to me entirely. Wentworth’s 1950s detective novel would come home with me because of the knitting, and because of the scones.

He reached for one of Hannah’s scones, feather light and sinfully enriched with both butter and honey.

The book has been one of the most pleasurable reads I can remember; Wentworth’s prose is descriptive and precise, and her heroine – the admirable Miss Silver – reminds me somehow of my wonderful late Godmother, Aunty Hilary who would definitely have approved of the fictitious character’s sensible fashions, fine scones and self-discipline. There is something extremely comforting to me about the competence of Patricia Wentworth’s heroine. I love the structure which Miss Silver imposes on her business;

Of the two newspapers subscribed to by Miss Silver it was her habit to peruse the lighter and more pictorial at breakfast, reserving the solid fare provided by The Times for a later and more leisured hour.

However perhaps the most enjoyable aspect of the book is the manner in which Miss Silver’s knitting is portrayed. I am sure that Patricia Wentworth must herself have been a knitter, otherwise I doubt that she might so accurately have portrayed the details and timings of the projects Miss Silver works on during the case of the Poison in the Pen. The pace at which a child’s twin-set is worked on throughout the novel is completely believable, and the documentation of Miss Silver’s knitting works as an excellent means for conveying the passage of time.

I also enjoy how Wentworth explores the relationship between listening and knitting. As you know this is a relationship which I enjoy exploring from many angles. However, until I encountered Wentworth’s writing I had not considered the many contexts for knitting and listening which might occur in crime fiction narratives. Silver’s knitting projects generally make their most conspicuous appearances during moments of problem-solving, conjecture or in key discussions with the Chief Constable, Randal.

For example in a section where Miss Silver is talking to Randal, her attentive qualities are highlighted through references to her knitting. In the third reference, drawing on a ball of yarn seems somehow to be a euphemism for reaching inwards to consider the topic of discussion more seriously, and to weigh up whether or not she wants to take the case:

She knitted thoughtfully. – p.15

The blue frill which depended from the needles was lenthening. Miss Silver said,
He spoke with a return to his usual manner. – p.16

She drew upon her ball of wool. – p.17

In another example where knitting-related activities and listening take place, the constant disarranging of a skein of yarn which Miss Silver is trying to wind serves as a sort of metaphor for the emotional disorder of one of the characters in the book. Too, the competence of Miss Silver in her needlework in this section underscores that she somehow has the upper-hand in this exchange with Miss Renie:

Miss Silver was winding the red wool which she had bought at Ashley’s. It always kept so much better in balls and Miss Renie having offered to hold the skeins for her, the two ladies were brought into very close proximity. Nothing could have exceeded the sympathetic warmth of Miss Silver’s attention…
…”How well you put it. Oh dear, I’m afraid I have tangled the skein! How stupid of me!”
Miss Silver adjusted the skein with the dexterity of long practice.
“Now if you will just keep it quite taut. I do not really think that you should reproach yourself for being concerned about Connie Brooke. It is a very sad accident, and must be felt by all her friends.”
Miss Renie sniffed.
“I did think she looked as if she had been crying at the rehearsal, but one couldn’t have dreamed – ”
Miss Silver said “Yes?” in a manner that made a question of it. The skein dropped again, Miss Renie burst into tears. – p. 94

Later in the story, Miss Silver attends a Work Party as a pretext for undertaking her murder investigation. The Work Party “which begun during the way, had proved itself so pleasant a social gathering that it had established itself as a permanency. There were, unfortunately, always the displaced and the distressed to work for, and no lack of piteous appeals for their relief. The party met at a different house each week, and its members vied with each other in the provision of simple refreshments.” It is most interesting to glimpse Stitch’n’Bitch Britain in the 1950s via Wentworth’s description here, and her description of the atmosphere therein is not that different from knit gatherings of today:

They came back into the room and disposed themselves on the comfortable old-fashioned chairs and sofas. Thimbles were put on, scissors laid ready, half-made garments produced, knitting-needles and wool extracted from capacious bags. Miss Silver found herself on a sofa next to a large and important looking lady in black and white tweeds. – p.117

The tweed-clad lady on the sofa beside Miss Silver turns out to be Lady Mallett, and perhaps of all the uses of knitting in the book to set the scene for excellent listening, this is my favourite. I especially like how Miss Silver draws a lot of information out of Lady Mallett under the pretext of working on her knitting project, and how her project affords her an ingenious means of infiltrating the social spheres of Ledshire. I also enjoy further references here to the capabilities of Miss Silver, where references to her excellent handicraft skills emphasise her overall brilliance as a person (and a detective).

“How very well you knit… I’m Nora Mallett – Lady Mallett. I’m a relation of the Reptons, and I’m here under completely false pretences, because I really came over to see Maggie… If I had any idea there would be this Work Party business going on I shouldn’t have come. As it is, I’m just waiting for a chance to get Maggie to myself for five minutes, so I don’t want to get involved with anyone if it will be difficult to get away from.”
Oddly enough, this bluntness did not give offence. There was so much warmth in voice and manner, so strong an impression of kindness, as to make her seem merely frank. Miss Silver found herself forming a favourable impression. She said with a smile,
“My own work, I am afraid, is of quite a private character. I am making a twin set for my niece’s little girl. The jumper is finished. This is the cardigan.”
…Nora Mallett’s tongue was notoriously indiscreet, but she would probably have not proceeded further if is had not been for that something about the quality of Miss Silver’s listening which had caused her to receive to many confidences… pp. 117-8

Later on in the novel, the near-completion of Miss Silver’s cardigan occurs almost synonymously with a pivotal discussion relating to the murder case. There is a wonderful key discussion between Randal and Silver in this section, wherein Silver’s knitting progress seems to hasten in tandem with the organisation of all of the information which will help the mystery murder to be solved. Twists and turns in the plot as Randal and Silver thrash out all the facts together are reflected in ever-increasing progress re: the knitwear on Miss Silver’s needles. It is hard not to imagine that Wentworth enjoyed closing both the murder case and the cardigan part of the twin-set with something of a flourish:

The crochet hook went in and out, drawing the blue wool into the trellised edging…

She put away her work and rose.
“Will you question her again?”

All of this has made me think that I need to explore more the context of the mature, female, private detective and depictions of knitting in literature. I wonder if intelligent and technical uses of knitting to delineate competence in a character are widespread, or if Wentworth’s wonderful Miss Silver is a lone example in a world which seems otherwise abundant with annoying, ill-researched and belittling depictions of “Knitting Nanas?” (I am thinking of the obscenely stupid Shreddies advert).

I would love your thoughts on this. Firstly, have you read any Wentworth? Secondly, am I deluded in thinking that Poison in the Pen uses knitting ingeniously well within plot to outline the capabilities, superior listening skills and subversive power of a female heroine? and thirdly, have you come across any wonderful essays which explore the iconic figure of the mature female private detective from a feminist perspective? I would love to know!

10 Responses to Meeting Miss Silver

  1. Julie Shrimpton says:

    Have you read Barbara Pym? Many knitting references in No Fond Return of Love & Some Tame Gazelle & A Glass of Blessings. For comedic purposes rather than detective. Agree about the Shreddies ad. Have you noticed also that the more recent Miss Marples can’t actually knit? They’re shown holding needles and wool but look rather awkward when they knit.

  2. Abbie says:

    I love British novels from the 1930s, 40s, and 50s – D.E. Stevenson and Elizabeth Goudge in particular. Thank you for introducing me to another author from that period! I just checked the catalog for my local library, the venerable Enoch Pratt Free Library in Baltimore, and it has a large selection of her books. I will have to visit there soon.

    I haven’t read any of the Miss Marple books by Agatha Christie, but the TV depictions of her always show her knitting furiously when she is in the throes of putting all the threads of information together to solve a mystery. I wonder if Patricia Wentworth was influenced by Agatha Christie’s writing when she created Miss Silver’s character.

    That makes me think that there are a lot of yarn and fabric-related phrases having to do with finding a solution to something: tying up loose ends, putting threads together, untangling a web, etc.

    Thank you for an interesting read this morning!

  3. tomofholland says:

    Richard Rutt collected novels in which knitting takes place. Clearly another Knitting Reference Library visit is in order!
    How wonderful to read about your discovery.

  4. colleen says:

    Marvellous! Such a pleasure to find a clever woman in detective fiction, especially one who most definitely does not have to behave like a chap. Unfortunately my answers to all of your questions are no though. I’m sure that someone, somewhere must have written a dissertation about women detectives, mature or otherwise, though. Was there any suggestion in the book that the knitting is also a bit of cover for her cleverness, a lure to deceive those who might dismiss her as being unable to detect the culprit? The comforting and hypnotic sound of knitting in a drawing room might easily encourage people to share secrets they might normally hid perhaps?

  5. Hanneke says:

    I loved reading your review of this book.I’m a big fann of old detective novels ( Sayers, Christie, March ) and think the miss Silver novels sadly overlooked when they describe the grand ladies of crime.
    I do love a good miss Silver novel. At first i was a little dissapointed in the books but then i got my hands on an english paperback and discovered they were just poorly trancelated in to dutch.

    Hace you ever read any Gladys Mitchell? her heroine is not at al like a marple of a silver but she does knit. Not as much or in such details as in the wenthworth books. But sometime they do serve the plot.

  6. What a marvellous find. This actually got me quite emotional…

    Unfortunately I haven’t got an answer to any of your questions right now but plan to do a bit of research and see if I can come up with anything. Isn’t it a weird coincidence that you should pick out this book. Coincidences never seize to amaze me.

    On a private note. Your tweed badges smile at me every day from my knitting basket. Lovely!


  7. Anna says:

    Thank you for sharing! If you intend to write more on the subject, I am sure your readers would appreciate.

  8. Jo says:

    What a lovely, thoughtful account. I can’t say that I’ve come across Wentworth myself. The quotes that you gave remind me of Miss Marple. I don’t recall her knitting but as a sensible lady detective there are definitely some similarities.
    I’m sure that you are spot on with the idea that the progress of the knitting in some way complements the progress of the case.
    I get a lovely, warm fuzzy feeling when I see a blog from you nestling in my inbox, between all the ‘junk’ emails! There was one from Ferg too this morning so I’ve had a super start to my day.
    Thank you x

  9. Julia says:

    I’ll have to look for the Miss Silver books! With Miss Marple, I always had the feeling that the knitting was part of her “harmless little old lady” costume, something meant to disarm those she was interviewing surreptitiously. I like how Wentworth is presenting knitting more as a sign of competence, and as a parallel process to thinking through a problem. Sometimes a knitting project IS a mystery! Very interesting link you have noted between knitting and listening – I think you’ve got something there.

  10. Kata. says:

    I read your wonderful post and longed to read one of miss Wentworth’s novels .. now I have discovered that there are two other titles in Tartu after all!

    And Wikipedia kindly informed me that Wentworth has written 32 novels with miss Silver as the main character, in addition to 34 other novels. She must have been writing as fast as she was knitting!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Copyright statement

You may transmit content found on this website (excluding my knitting patterns which are protected under International copyright law) under the following conditions:

- You always attribute my work to me, Felicity Ford, including a link back to this site
- You do not alter my work
- You do not use my work for commercial purposes

To discuss any other uses of my work, please contact me directly on the telephone number and email address provided at the top of this blog.

Creative Commons License
All the work shown here by Felicity Ford is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

From time to time I feature images, sounds or words on this blog which are not my own: in all such cases the original copyright owner is named. International copyright law requires that in order to republish their content, you must seek out their permission.

Thank you for respecting these terms and conditions.

Search Form
%d bloggers like this: